Media, culture, and politics from an aesthetic-materialist's perspective.
Thursday, October 25, 2007
Facebook Revolutions
The BBC goes on to state 15 useful, sometimes obvious reasons why a mega-corporation like Microsoft would want to invest in the world's premier social networking website. Here are my favorites:
2. The average user spends 3.5 hours a month on Facebook - more than the average user on rival MySpace - which is increasingly attractive to advertisers.
I personally know people who spend this much time on Facebook every day. I shall not name names here, but let's just say I now know why the United Nations has a reputation for not getting anything done.
3. Facebook is the current Web 2.0 darling - popular with ordinary users and "tech heads" alike.
I don't know the lingo: 2.0, tech head, whatever. I do know I'm a half-Luddite when it comes to technology: happy with the tools, functions, and gadgets I possess and know well but averse to "new" and "innovative" commodities that I'm told I simply "must have" in order to be "cool" or "with it" or "in touch." I still resent those moments when friends had the audacity to criticize me for not having a cell phone -- as though they had to put up with some sort of unfortunate handicap on my part. I'm happy with my mobile now, but it's not like I was dying without it.
At any rate, this is an interesting point: Facebook appeals to techies and non-techies alike. For me, it's not just that Facebook's applications are efficient and easy to use; it's also that the website's text and interface are "easy on the eyes," designed with the student or working professional in mind. MySpace, by contrast, has turned into a gauche, untidy, bloated mess of advertising, videos, and "personalized" text; every page is a new adventure, and usually a new set of buttons and images and objects to navigate or avoid. MySpace has no common "language" to speak of -- it's become so "user-friendly" that any semblance of communicable text is lost between a set of five or more "friends."
4. US research reveals that Facebook users come from wealthier homes and are more likely to attend college than MySpace users - increasing that attraction for advertisers.
But of course my rant above probably boils down to this revealing fact: though by no means from a "wealthy" family, I do have the education, leisure time, and cultural capital to appreciate certain aspects of Facebook -- design, clarity, efficiency -- over and against those of MySpace. Rather than feel "guilty" about this fact, I'd like to think through the implications of Facebook's class differential and, more broadly, theorize how and to what effect capital identifies virtual spaces of consumption. These spaces are variable and differentiated; they may be porous, or they may not. However one pursues these questions, it's important that we remember Facebook's isolationist "origins": it began as a virtual complement to Harvard's freshman facebook, print copies of which had been a new student's guide to everyone's hometown, campus location, and hookup potentiality (the last based on a choice high school photo -- gah!). They had actual facebooks when I arrived at Dartmouth in the fall of 2001 -- are they still around at "elite" colleges and universities, or has Facebook replaced them too?
9. According to a report, 233 million hours of work are lost each month in the UK due to staff looking at social networks. Advertisers can now target people when at their desks.
See comment about UN workers above.
14. Facebook is the acceptable face of blogging - you can reflect your life and personality online without being seen as a "blogger", which often carries a geeky stigma.
Well, this can go both ways -- too little information on Facebook leaves you in the doldrums (see those who still have the question mark as their profile picture), but too much can make it seem as though you only knew how to communicate in spaces of virtual sociality. I've been told that my practice of posting numerous reviews of books and movies on Facebook (and Amazon.com) is odd. What makes me want to offer criticism in these virtual spaces? What do I get done here that I may or may not be able to get done in "real life"? Do I expose myself to be averse to face-to-face interaction by channeling a portion of my intellectual energy into Facebook -- or this blog even?
All good questions, the answers to which aren't forthcoming any time soon (if ever). I suppose the only thing I can say right now is that I'm aware of the existential tension between my virtual self and my Being as such. I realize that, even though virtuality is definitely a part of my Being, it doesn't exhaust or define who I am in a strict sense. I mean, have you seen my Facebook profile picture? When have I ever looked so cool in real life?
Wednesday, September 26, 2007
Lost Luggage Graveyard/Sale
It is the warehouse of the lost and never found, the final destination of airline luggage that goes missing in the US and is never reclaimed.
The building is situated on the edge of the sleepy town of Scottsboro in Alabama.
It does not seem like the kind of place that would attract a million visitors a year, but bargain hunters from around the world converge on the centre every day, eager to see what treasures the Unclaimed Baggage Center has uncovered.
It is a company that buys all the lost and unclaimed luggage from airlines across the US and then sells on everything from clothes to expensive jewellery at discount prices.
"When they come in, we always tell people to plan a few hours to go on their treasure hunt," says Brenda Cantrell, the centre's marketing manager.
"Dig through it, have fun with it, you never know what you might find."
Sight unseen
The luggage is only sold to the Unclaimed Baggage Center once 90 days have passed, and the owners have not been traced.
They receive it, sight unseen, and then unpack, sort and display the items inside the warehouse that is the size of a city block.
For the most part that means clothes, rows and rows of them, but it also means some very unusual and valuable items, sometimes sewn into the linings of cases or hidden in crates.
"We had a 19th Century full suit of armour, an underwater camera from Nasa, Egyptian artefacts and props from movies," says Brenda as she proudly stands next to a display case that holds a puppet from the Jim Henson film, Labyrinth.
He was discovered staring out at the staff in a packing case back in the 1980s. His name is Hoggle and he now resides in the centre's museum along with a set of bagpipes, and ancient maps of Afghanistan.
Over the years, shoppers have made their own special finds.
One woman discovered $1,000 (£500) hidden in the lining of a case she bought for pocket change, while another found out that the glass vase she had bought as a trinket was actually worth a small fortune.
"I was here Friday, Saturday, yesterday and today and I'll probably come back tomorrow," says Abby Gentry-Benson, who is festooned with diamonds, silver and gold jewellery all purchased at the Unclaimed Baggage Center.
Abby, who describes herself as a Chanel No. 5 girl, has been coming to the warehouse for more than 30 years and bought most of her jewellery for around half-price.
Her entire collection is worth a great deal, and she feels no guilt that many of the items were possibly heirlooms or precious keepsakes.
"Most of the pieces that people have lost, they got the insurance money from and have bought something to replace it. Somebody like me that loves it and cherishes it every day, it's got a good home you know."
Finders keepers
Over in the sporting goods and electronics section there are piles of mobile phones, ever popular iPods, golf clubs, a ukulele (with one string), and even a shotgun that was misplaced by one careless owner.
Steve Mare and his mother-in-law have flown all the way from Texas just to visit the warehouse.
"Both of us had heard about it for years and we wanted to come and see what bargains we could find," says Steve, who is looking for a new suitcase.
The Unclaimed Baggage Center started down the road in a shack, when the founder began the business by buying lost luggage from the Greyhound Bus Company.
In those days things were literally thrown onto a table and people sorted through, in search of a bargain.
But now the centre is one of Alabama's top tourist destinations proving that "finders keepers, losers weepers" is a big attraction for those in search of a new suit of clothes or a suit of armour.Monday, June 25, 2007
Cameron Got Served, or, Sendero Luminoso Revisited
While touring the famed Inca ruins of Machu Picchu, Diaz sported an olive-green bag that featured a red star and the phrase, "Serve the People," in Chinese characters. This phrase is known to be one of the hallmark slogans of Mao Zedong's Chinese Communist Party.
The problem? News sources say that Peruvians are especially sensitive to such symbology because it is reminiscent of the bloody guerrilla war that the Maoist group Shining Path, or Sendero Luminoso, waged in the country throughout the 1980s and up to the early '90s. Close to 70,000 people are thought to have perished as a result of the war, but news agencies have omitted the fact that Sendero Luminoso is said to be responsible for 31,331 of those casualties. According to Human Rights Watch, government security forces were responsible for a third of the killings; the remaining deaths are mostly unattributed.
Without condoning the actions of Sendero Luminoso, I think it's important to properly frame the statistics people are citing with regard to the war. It's clear that both the group's actions and the Peruvian government's response to those actions were reckless and drastic -- together they had the effect of making paranoia and violence a part of everyday life. Indeed the war created the social conditions for what the anthropologist Michael Taussig calls "terror as usual."
Diaz, we know, was unaware of this significant aspect of Peruvian history. A Peruvian civil rights activist (on whom news agencies rely to voice the collective opinion of Peruvians who are or would be or have been offended by Diaz's bag), Pablo Rojas, is quoted as saying: "[The bag] alludes to a concept that did so much damage to Peru, that brought about so many victims... I don't think she should have used that bag where the followers of that ideology did so much damage."
Rojas is entirely justified in making this statement, but it seems to me the lack of world-historical knowledge Diaz displayed is hardly unusual for the privileged tourist who travels abroad. I dare say that most American travelers to Peru know next to nothing of the country's history, recent or otherwise. Diaz (who grew up in Australia) is your average tourist; it's her celebrity (cameras focused on her) and pseudo-political chic (where political symbology and slogans are now marketed for fashionable consumption) that led to this cultural misunderstanding.
Rojas's actual target of criticism, then, is not Cameron Diaz the "person" but Cameron Diaz the star-image. The blame for this episode of cultural insensitivity might be equally shared among Diaz's entourage: her publicist, her fashion consultant, her image-makers. Note how the olive-green bag is meant to complement Diaz's "backpacker look": loose clothing, a hat to shield her face from the sun, and what appears to be a hemp bracelet (or one made of a similarly organic material). The only flourish I can detect in these photos is a purple scarf (or two?) rolled around Diaz's neck. At any rate, the bag's political sloganeering is but one fashionable element in a complete celebrity package.
Perhaps blame should also be attributed to the brichero, or "native" tour guide, who appears next to Diaz on Machu Picchu. Note the designer sweater and unsullied jeans -- this guy really came prepared.
The brichero's beaming gaze and I'm-all-ears stance say it all: entranced by Diaz's beauty, that inimitable smile, that aura of Hollywood celebrity, our guide likely didn't even notice the remnant of Maoist symbology that emblazons the bag in question.
Tuesday, May 8, 2007
Violence & Attention
As you can read for yourself, Shriver's basic claim is that violent acts like Cho's are, in part, made possible -- even encouraged -- by a media culture that feeds off sensationalism and extorts emotional baggage. It's a culture that capitalizes on shock and awe even in the midst of tragedy. It's a culture that somehow validates "being seen" at any cost. Shriver writes, "In an era that has lost touch with the distinction between fame and infamy, so driving is the need to be noticed -- for any reason -- that even posthumous attention will do."
What I like about Shriver's piece is that it doesn't shy away from asking tough, critical questions about the way we've received news about this no doubt horrific event -- how it's been framed, in what ways we are led to crave more information, and so on. Of course it's not that we shouldn't receive news about unpleasant events at all; the issue, rather, is how to avoid legitimating (by consuming) the very culture of media sensationalism that contributed to Cho's belief that he really could be a quasi-martyr. Much attention has been given to the influence violent Japanese manga and the South Korean film Oldboy might have had on Cho. But perhaps the better analogy is to Oliver Stone's satire Natural Born Killers, in which a modern-day Bonnie and Clyde go on a killing spree that the media covers obsessively and effectively wants to go on.
Shriver is less convincing, I think, when she says there's absolutely nothing that can change this culture of media sensationalism. It's highly unlikely (a "pipe dream"), she says, that the media will cease giving "blanket coverage and banner headlines" to these killers. And because, thankfully, we don't live in a police state (though the post-9/11, Patriot Act States would seem to challenge that assumption), the simple fact of the matter is that "Whenever we walk out the door, we take the chance that malice will rain on our heads."
It may be the case that nothing can change the media's voracious efforts to "grab" the audience's attention, no matter what the cost. But if this is the case, it seems to me much more effort should be put into media education -- that is, learning to observe, consume, and participate in media as critical subjects. A key component of this type of knowledge, I would argue, is the Marxian/Debordian understanding that consumer society renders us alienated subjects and has the potential to exhaust our ability to rely on ourselves, and each other (i.e., human contact), for emotional, spiritual, intellectual, and physical sustenance. Whenever we don't feel sustained in our human relationships, we turn to sundry consumer outlets -- not least mass media -- to again feel whole, or perhaps to be distracted for a while, or even to replace that lack with a fleeting desire (i.e., shopping).
In Cho's case, it's clear he had found "real life" to be so harsh and unwelcoming that he accepted he had no other choice but to stage a (posthumous) media frenzy that would grant him the attention he so desperately sought. Cho was, in short, a thoroughly alienated soul. Further pathologizing him as a "wacko" or "kook" or even a "South Korean," not American, national ("It's not us, good heavens!") neglects Cho's rather common affliction: wanting to be wanted in a hyperreal world.